What were pros and cons of stalin's 5 year plans?

Answer 1

Stalin planed to increase industrialization. The plan increased industrial and agricultural output by 50 per cent in the five years. The cost in human lives is difficult to measure.

Answer 2

Stalin's Five Year Plan increased manufacturing but decreased production of consumer goods.

The Five-Year Plan was a road map for Stalin's great goals of industrialization. The industrial output of the Soviet Union increased by 50 percent in five years; the annual rate of growth during the first Five-Year Plan was between 15 and 22 percent. There were entirely new industries built in entirely new cities. Cities such as Moscow and Leningrad doubled in size in the early 1930s. Stalin attempted a Moscow-White Sea canal connecting Moscow to the seaports of the north.

However, this industrialization came at enormous human cost. Many large-scale projects were carried out with prison labor. People were arrested and sent to camps on all sorts of charges (petty criminal infractions, contacting foreigners, and even being born to bourgeoisie or kulak parents). This army of prisoners was supposed to complete the most tedious tasks ever.

Heavy industry was always in priority over light industry. Emphasis on quantity even made quality practically meaningless.

Stalin's Five-Year Plans consisted of a countless number of moves for further industrialization of Russia. A few examples were given above.

Method of planning economic growth over limited periods, through the use of quotas, used first in the Soviet Union and later in other socialist states. In the Soviet Union, the first Five-Year Plan (1928 - 32), implemented by Joseph Stalin, concentrated on developing heavy industry and collectivizing agriculture, at the cost of a drastic fall in consumer goods. The second plan (1933 - 37) continued the objectives of the first. Collectivization led to terrible famines, especially in the Ukraine, that caused the deaths of millions. The third (1938 - 42) emphasized the production of armaments. The fourth (1946 - 53) again stressed heavy industry and military buildup, angering the Western powers. In China, the first Five-Year Plan (1953 - 57) stressed rapid industrial development, with Soviet assistance; it proved highly successful. Shortly after the second plan began in 1958, the Great Leap Forward was announced; its goals conflicted with the five-year plan, leading to failure and the withdrawal of Soviet aid in 1960.

Stalin's Five-Year Plan was a road map for a great campaign of forced industrialization. It was a rather ambitious set of goals that Stalin and his followers drew up in 1927. The plan called for unbelievable industrialization efforts. Russian propaganda posters advocated the saying "We Smite Lazy Workers!" to mobilize workers. New industries were built in entirely new cities (i.e. the factory town of Magnitogorsk). Moscow and Leningard doubled in size as new cities were emerging across the country.

The results of the five-year plan are still looked upon today as one of the most stunning periods of economic growth. The industrial output of the Soviet Union increased by 50% in five years. In 1926, only 1/5 people in the Soviet Union lived in towns. In 1939, roughly 1/3 did.

Yet, this is not to say that this was totally executed without some defects. This industrialization came at enormous human cost. Large-scale projects in the timber and mining industries used prison labor. The labor camp system (named "gulag") actually became a central component of the Stalinist economic system. People were arrested and sent to camps on a very wide variety of charges, including simply having the ill luck of being born to bourgeois or kulak parents. This camp system held around 3.6 million people by the end of the decade. A man-made canal connecting Moscow to the seaports of the north was dug by hand, with human labor used for every part of its construction. Tens of thousands lives were lost. (Yet, the canal was bombed early in World War II).

These were economic plans setting out timed goals for productivity, especially with regard to industrial output.

In 1927 Stalin's advisers told him that with the modernization of farming the Soviet Union would require an extra 250,000 tractors. As well as tractors there was also a need to develop the oil fields to provide the necessary petrol to drive the machines. Power stations also had to be built to supply the farms with electricity.

Since the October Revolution industrial progress had been slow. It was not until 1927 that production had reached the levels achieved before the start of the First World War. Stalin decided that he would use his control over the country to increase production.

The first Five Year Plan introduced in 1928, concentrated on the development of iron and steel, machine-tools, electric power and transport. Joseph Stalin set the workers high targets. He demanded a 1115 increase in coal production, 200% increase in iron production and 335% increase in electric power. He justified these demands by claiming that if rapid industrialization did not take place, the Soviet Union would not be able to defend itself against an invasion from capitalist countries in the west.

Every factory had large display boards erected that showed the output of workers. Those that failed to reach the required targets were publicity criticized and humiliated. Some workers could not cope with this pressure and absenteeism increased. This led to even more repressive measures being introduced. Records were kept of workers' lateness, absenteeism and bad workmanship. If the worker's record was poor, he was accused of trying to sabotage the Five Year Plan and if found guilty could be shot or sent to work as forced labour on the Baltic Sea Canal or the Siberian Railway.

With the introduction of the Five Year Plan, Stalin argued that it was necessary to pay higher wages to certain workers in order to encourage increased output. His left-wing opponents claimed that this inequality was a betrayal of socialism and would create a new class system in the Soviet Union. Stalin had his way and during the 1930s, the gap between the wages of the labourers and the skilled workers increased.

To improve agricultural and industrial production

To improve the production rate by 80%

Stalin's Five-Year Plan was a road map for a great campaign of forced industrialization. It was a rather ambitious set of goals that Stalin and his followers drew up in 1927. The plan called for unbelievable industrialization efforts. Russian propaganda posters advocated the saying "We Smite Lazy Workers!" to mobilize workers. New industries were built in entirely new cities (i.e. the factory town of Magnitogorsk). Moscow and Leningard doubled in size as new cities were emerging across the country.

The results of the five-year plan are still looked upon today as one of the most stunning periods of economic growth. The industrial output of the Soviet Union increased by 50% in five years. In 1926, only 1/5 people in the Soviet Union lived in towns. In 1939, roughly 1/3 did.

Yet, this is not to say that this was totally executed without some defects. This industrialization came at enormous human cost. Large-scale projects in the timber and mining industries used prison labor. The labor camp system (named "gulag") actually became a central component of the Stalinist economic system. People were arrested and sent to camps on a very wide variety of charges, including simply having the ill luck of being born to bourgeois or kulak parents. This camp system held around 3.6 million people by the end of the decade. A man-made canal connecting Moscow to the seaports of the north was dug by hand, with human labor used for every part of its construction. Tens of thousands lives were lost.

Russia had been a mostly agrarian state, but the world was moving toward industrialization. Stalin realized that for the USSR to keep up economically with the rest of the world, it had to become more industrialized as well. The plans also were intended to increase agricultural output, but were not as successful in that regard as they were in industrializing the country.

Answer 3

Pros: Rapid industrialization of the Soviet Union. Cons: People died for productivity. In essence, people died in steel factories, others were banished to Siberia by the communist party, and others were killed because of stalinist tactics.

Answer 4

The Five Year Plans were created to serve in the rapid industrialisation of the Soviet Union, and therefore placed a major focus on heavy industry. Some were successfully completed earlier than expected, while others failed and were abandoned.

The First Five Year Plan did achieve a few successes such as a great economic improvement, a steady economy, military improvements and new jobs which lead to a tripling in the number of workers. People were no longer afraid not to have enough money to survive with a big family, unemployment was almost non-existent. "No fear of wage reduction in a land where none are unemployed" said Dr Hewlett Johnson. On the otherhand, . The problems with this first plan were the awful working conditions and the fact that those who refused to work were sent awful into exile.

The second Five Year Plan communications, especially railways, became faster. This Second Plan failed to reach the recommended production levels in such crucial areas as coal and oil. During this second Five Year Plan, Childcare was introduced so women could work more. By 1937 women were 40% of industrial workers, 21% of building workers and 72% of health workers. Four out of five new workers recruited between 1932 and 1937 were women.

The Third Five Year Plan succeeded in producing enough oil and the output of steel but generally failed to reach its target. However this plan did fail for the reason that many factories ran short on materials due to the beginning of World War Two. This plan only lasted three years because it was disrupted due to the outbreak of the Second World War in 1939

Answer 5

5tu