0
Had every athenian citizen been a socrates every athenian assembly would still have been a mob?
Wiki User
∙ 14y ago
Athens was governed by an assembly of all adult male citizens, which met fortnightly to make decisions.
These assembly meetings were swayed by orators, and often acted in irrational and damaging ways as a result [example: a lot of sailors of sunken ships were drowned after a sea battle at Arginusai when a storm came up. Theramenes was the Admiral charged with recovering them. He got home early before the others, and told the Assembly that the other Admirals had deserted the dying sailors, and their relatives demanded execution of the admirals. This was passed by the Assembly and carried out (one the six executed was Pericles, son of the famous, now deceased Pericles), and cunning Theramenes got off scot free.
The majority of the people was democratically inclined. Socrates was in favour of power to a limited number of the better educated conservatives. If the conservatives (read Socrates clones) had been in the majority, the Assembly would still have been swayed by orators but in a different direction - group-think, a mob, thinking differently but still a mob.
We have tried today to limit this in our democracies by using representative democracy - elected members of parliament who meet and are supposedly not prone to on-the-spot mass surges of opinion and direction. It works partially.
Wilhelmine Rolfson
Wiki User
∙ 14y agoThis is a quotation from James Madison
in Federalist 55. It captures Madison's argument that the structure of a representative body can be decisive for the way that body operates and, therefore, for the quality of its product. In particular, the claim here is that once it reaches a certain size a group of people can become too large to reach decisions based upon sharing ideas and arguing about which among them might be better. Instead, anybody can become so large that meaningful deliberation is simply impossible and the decisions are made solely on the basis of speeches and voting rather than through a process of sharing ideas and deciding.
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
How did Roman law protect those accused of crimes?
Roman law gave every citizen the right to a trial.Roman law gave every citizen the right to a trial.Roman law gave every citizen the right to a trial.Roman law gave every citizen the right to a trial.Roman law gave every citizen the right to a trial.Roman law gave every citizen the right to a trial.Roman law gave every citizen the right to a trial.Roman law gave every citizen the right to a trial.Roman law gave every citizen the right to a trial.
In Athens during the Age of Pericles every male citizen did what?
Was entitled to attend the assembly and speak and vote on issues raised by them or others. They also served in the army and navy when called out.
In Greek culture music was an important part of the education of every Greek citizen. In the Roman culture music was?
not as highly valued (Apex)
How did the Greek and Roman versions of democracy differ?
Greek, particularly Athenian, Democracy was a participatory democracy. The number of people who were allowed citizenship was comparatively small; so each citizen was expected to attend public meetings such as the Assembly, which was the city council meeting. The juries numbered 500 instead of the twelve of the English jury system. Every property owning male of eligible age, both of whose parents were born in Athens had a civic responsibility to participate. Rome was a republic. Each class, aristocrats, equestrians, and plebeians, elected representatives for selected offices. The aristocrats sat in the senate, which was the deliberative body, made most of the decisions, but some decisions were subject to plebiscite, the approval of the lower classes, similar to a California referendum, today.
How did the people rule Athens?
Every free man over a certain age was considered a citizen. (No Women) All citizens were allowed to attend meetings in which new laws, and actions were voted on by all who attended. Citizens were never required to attend, and they would not attend every meeting. Athens was governed in this way, and is considered the first true democracy.
What do this mean Had every Athenian citizen been a Socrates every Athenian assembly would still have been a mob?
This quote by Plato suggests that even if all citizens were as wise and just as Socrates, the democratic process in Athens would still lead to chaotic and often irrational outcomes. Despite individual virtues, the collective decision-making of a large group can be influenced by emotions, biases, and lack of understanding.
What is the meaning of Had every Athenian citizen been a Socrate's every Athenian assembly would still have been a mob?
This quote suggests that even if every Athenian citizen possessed the wisdom and intellect of Socrates, the collective decision-making process in the Athenian assembly would still be chaotic and disorderly. It implies that the nature of crowds and group dynamics can often lead to irrational or tumultuous outcomes, regardless of the individual qualities of the participants.
Every year the members of the Athenian Assembly chose the Council of 500 by?
demorcratic vote
What is one advantage of Athenian democracy?
It gave precedence to the idea that every citizen had the right to self determination.
What does Had every Athenian citizen been a Socrates every Athenian assembly would still have been a mob mean?
Athens was governed by an assembly of all adult male citizens, which met fortnightly to make decisions.These assembly meetings were swayed by orators, and often acted in irrational and damaging ways as a result [example: a lot of sailors of sunken ships were drowned after a sea battle at Arginusai when a storm came up. Theramenes was the Admiral charged with recovering them. He got home early before the others, and told the Assembly that the other Admirals had deserted the dying sailors, and their relatives demanded execution of the admirals. This was passed by the Assembly and carried out (one the six executed was Pericles, son of the famous, now deceased Pericles), and cunning Theramenes got off scot free.The majority of the people was democratically inclined. Socrates was in favour of power to a limited number of the better educated conservatives. If the conservatives (read Socrates clones) had been in the majority, the Assembly would still have been swayed by orators but in a different direction - group-think, a mob, thinking differently but still a mob.We have tried today to limit this in our democracies by using representative democracy - elected members of parliament who meet and are supposedly not prone to on-the-spot mass surges of opinion and direction. It works partially.
The assembly of all athenian citizen which met to discuss and vote on laws was called?
The law-making body of Athens was called the Ekklesia, or the Assembly. The Assembly was composed of any Athenian citizen who cared to show up - that is, any Athens-born male over the age of 18. Women and slaves were not allowed to participate. All classes of society, however, from wealthy landowners to the thetes, or manual laborers, were allowed to participate. Before Pericles' reforms, however, only those wealthy enough to have significant amounts of free time on their hands could show up regularly to meetings. The leader of each meeting of the Assembly were chosen by lottery, with every male citizen over 18 having an equal chance of being drawn. Some of the duties of the Assembly were to vote on laws and decide when to go to war.
6 How were Spartan and Athenian governments different?
Athens had a unique government, a direct democracy. This meant that every Athenian citizen voted on laws and legislation. Sparta was ruled by two kings and a 28 member council of elders.
Which best describes the Athenian government?
A direct democracy with enforced participation. ----------------------- Every Athenian male resident was a participant. However, women, slaves, children and foreigners were not included.
what is the difference between Athens and Sparta citizenship?
The Spartan government operated very differently than the Athenian government. Unlike Athens's democracy, in which every citizen had a vote, Sparta had an oligarchic government (a government ruled by a few people). Also the assembly could only vote on yes-or-no laws, but could not debate issues.
What was the assembly of ancient Sparta?
the assembly was open to every male citizen over the age of 30. met to talk about important matter such as rules about citizenship or war and to oppoint generals
What law gives us the right to picket?
The First Amendment gives every US citizen the right to assembly and to have his voice heard.
Who decides Court cases in Athens?
As part of the ancien Athenian assembly, the Council of 500 established the court cases. A prociding officer was chosen randomly from all citizens at every meating, and the assembly (whoever attended) voted. The cause with the most votes won.
