answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

This is a difficult question to answer, as the line between long battles, sieges, and what are now known as campaigns is a blurry one - often times, the distinction between them is merely an arbitrary line drawn by historians.

Theoretically, a battle should be a discrete event in time, location, and scope. That is, it should happen over a set period of time, with combat experiencing only very short pauses, though the intensity of combat may vary. It should happen in a well-defined geographic area that is not too large (how large is too large, is, once again, a matter of opinion). And, it should generally concern a relatively fixed number of combatants - that is, the participants of the battle should be those already in the geographic location, with some reinforcements coming from those forces in relative proximity to the battle area when the battle began.

Sieges aren't battles, because they violate the restrictions on time and scope - that is, a siege generally happens over a very long time, with huge gaps in actual fighting. Sieges also generally can encompass a wide variety of forces not initially near or engaged at the start of the siege.

Campaigns are what modern historians generally label a series of battles - that is, once combat exceeds the time, scope, and location constrictions of a battle, then the entire timeframe is considered a campaign, which is then broken down into battles or sieges.

Using the above definitions, one can see that looking for the "longest battle" becomes a real problem, as once combat exceeds more than a couple of days, the pauses become longer (reinforcing the tendency to break the "main" battle into a series of shorter battles), and the limits on scope blur rapidly, as forces further afield are brought in to fight.

In order to maintain a relatively drawn-out combat situation which fits the definition of battle, logistics become key, as maintaining constant combat is something that really has only become possible since the Industrial Revolution. Thus, any long-term "battle" prior to about 1850 should properly be labeled a siege or campaign; the two major American Revolutionary "battles": Saratoga and Yorktown, are more properly defined as a campaign and a siege.

Likewise, many WW1 and WW2 named battles ("Battle of Stalingrad", "Battle of the Bulge", "Battle of Britain", and "Battle of the Atlantic") aren't in any way battles, but in most cases, campaigns (Leningrad and Stalingrad being the exceptions, being sieges).

To get back to the original question: there is no good answer. Once a battle goes beyond a week or so, it generally can't be labeled a battle anymore, and belongs in one of the other two categories. Perhaps the great battles of WW1 might still be considered battles, but even there, months-long combat really was broken up into an initial effort, succeeded by a cycle of pauses, counteroffensives, and renewed offenses each which may have lasted a week or so, which made combat appear to last months. They're thus really just campaigns over a smaller-than-usual locality.

User Avatar

Wiki User

12y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar
More answers
User Avatar

Wiki User

16y ago

yugi vs marik istar

This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: What was the longest battle ever fought in world history?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Related questions

What was the longest war in World War I?

there is none. the longest war in world war 1 is world war 1. it would have to be the longest battle. :)*


What country defended the fortifications at verdun?

The Battle of Verdun, 21st February to 18th December 1916, was the largest and longest battle of the First World War. It was fought between the German and French armies.


What was the last world war 2 battle fought in the pacific battle?

Battle of Okinawa


What major battles were fought in Austria during World War 2?

The Battle for Castle Itter was a major battle that was fought in Austria during World War 2. It was fought in the final days of the war and the only battle that the Germans and Americans fought together as allies.


What was the last world was 2 battle fought in the pacific theater?

Battle of Okinawa


Where was the battle of cantigny fought in the first world war?

The Battle of Cantigny was fought in Cantigny, Sommes, France.


What were the two difficult battles fought by the allies in Italy?

One of the difficult battles fought by allies in Italy was called the battle of Monte Casino. This occurred in World War II and was fought by the Germans. The second difficult battle was also fought by German was called the battle of Ortona and was fought during World War II as well.


What was the important battle fought in Russia World War 2?

Probably the Battle of Stalingrad and the Battle of Kursk.


What was the largest battle fought in western Europe during World War 2?

The Battle of the Bulge


In ww2the islands near Australia where a main battle was fought were the?

In World War II, the islands near Australia where a main battle was fought were the ________. solomon islands


Who fought in the Battle of Berlin in world war 2?

Germany and Russia


Who fought in The battle of Atlantic in World War 2?

Us and the Japanese.