Best Answer

If the federal government can perform an enumerated power without a law or action, then that law or action is unnecessary and therefore unconstitutional.

User Avatar

Wiki User

14y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: How should the necessary and proper clause be interpreted?
Write your answer...
Still have questions?
magnify glass
Related questions

Why is the necessary and proper clause also called the elastic clause?

The Necessary and Proper Clause basically says that Congress can pass new amendments if needed. They don't have to just stick with the original Constitution. Therefore it's also called the Elastic Clause because it allows Congress a bit more flexibility within the Constitution. They can literally stretch the interpretation of it to allow for new legislation should the situation call for it.

What is the elastic clause-?

The elastic clause provides flexibility for our government.The elastic clause in the US Constitution grants Congress the right to pass all laws "necessary and proper" to carry out the powers specifically granted to Congress by the Constitution.

When President Thomas Jefferson acquired the Louisiana Territory from France he demonstrated that he modified his belief that?

the federal government should have strict interpretation of the Constitution. Previously, Jefferson had been a strict constructionist, believing that the federal government should only exercise powers explicitly granted to it by the Constitution. However, the Louisiana Purchase was not explicitly authorized by the Constitution, leading Jefferson to interpret the necessary and proper clause to justify the acquisition. This demonstrated his willingness to adapt his beliefs when necessary for the benefit of the country.

What is the importance of the elastic clause in the Constitution?

Elastic ClauseThe elastic clause, also known as the Necessary-and-Proper Clause, is found in Article I, section 8, of the Constitution. It authorizes Congress to pass all laws "necessary and proper" to carry out the enumerated (listed) powers of Congress. The clause allows Congress some degree of flexibility in enacting legislation. It gives the Congress more power than what is stated in the Constitution. Example--the government has the power to collect taxes. But, the Constitution does not say where that money should be held. It was argued that the Elastic Clause gave Congress the power to establish a National Bank to hold the money. It allows Congress to pass laws that are needed as time changes.

Why has the necessary and proper clause often been called the elastic clause?

It is called the elastic clause because it is elastic, in a figurative sense, it is written in a way that as times change and things in the world are different, parts to the clause, and whole constitution its self can be changed. But remember that to actually change or edit the constitution takes a lot of political power, not just one person can decide that there should be another amendment.

Should you put a comma before a time expression?

It is not usually necessary. You would only do it if the expression were an extra phrase or a clause.

How should Quran be interpreted?

The Quran should be interpreted in totality by reading all the other verses as well.

Why did jefferson and madision oppose the national bank?

They believed it was unconstitutional because it was not stated in the constitution that one of the powers of the federal government was to create a national bank. Hamilton however said that it was needed to enforce taxes and that because of the "necessary and proper" clause, they should create a national bank, so they did.

Why should history be interpreted for learners?


Hamilton's views on how the Constitution should be interpreted?

Jefferson wanted a strict interpretation to give more power to the states, while hamilton favored a broad interpretation to streengthen the central government. Also, Jefferson wanted to give the common people more opportunities to participate in government while hamilton believed commoners were ignorant and not capable of self-government

How do you punctuate sentence with 'if'?

If should be followed by a dependent clause, a comma, an independent clause and then a period.

What should follow a dependent clause when the dependent clause comes first in a sentence.?

A comma