answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

President Wilson, a Democrat, was engaged in a power struggle with a Republican controlled Senate. The conflict centered around a balance of power issue -- Wilson had negotiated the treaty without the customary presence of senators, and he neglected to discuss and negotiate the terms of the treaty with the Senate Foreign Relations committee before making it public. By cutting the senators out of the treaty making process, Wilson was attempting to do an end run around the Senate's authority over treaties and this angered many senators.

The Republicans also had major substantive and ideological issues with the proposed treaty. Some of these issues arose out the bitter, personal rivalry between the head of the Foreign Relations Committee, Henry Cabot Lodge and Wilson. These men had opposing views of international relations with Lodge being a realist and Wilson an idealist. Lodge and other Republican Senators believed the treaty should call for the unconditional surrender of Germany and it did not, they felt that many provisions as written were unenforceable, and they opposed the treaty provisions which authorized US participation in Wilson's pet project, the League of Nations. In particular, Lodge felt participation in the League would compromise US sovereignty by requiring the US to enter into international conflicts when it was not in the national interest of the US to do so. Lodge's committee sent the treaty to the floor of the Senate for a vote with 14 amendments, but recommended against its passage. On November 19, 1919, for the first time in US history, the Senate rejected a peace treaty.

User Avatar

Wiki User

15y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar
More answers
User Avatar

Wiki User

11y ago

Senator Lodge proposed 14 reservations aimed at limiting any kind of real commitment to mutual security with regards to the Treaty

This answer is:
User Avatar

User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago

why did Henry Cabot lodge to the treaty?

This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Why did Henry Cabot lodge have problems with the treat of Versailles?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about American Government
Related questions

What prominent US leader opposed the Treaty of Versailles?

Henry Cabot Lodge


Who was the opponent of the Treaty of Versailles?

Henry Cabot Lodge of Massachusetts.


Who was a powerful opponent for the Treaty of Versailles?

Henry Cabot Lodge of Massachusetts.


What is the birth name of Henry Cabot Lodge?

Henry Cabot Lodge's birth name is Lodge Jr., Henry Cabot.


What was Republican senator Henry Cabot Lodge's strategy regarding the Treaty of Versailles?

Delay and amend the treaty.


Who kept the Treaty of Versailles stalled in the foreign relations committee?

pretty sure it was Henry Cabot Lodge


Which senator blocked US ratification of Treaty of Versailles and US membership in League of Nations?

Henry Cabot Lodge


This person wanted to make changes in the Versailles Treaty before Congress would accept it?

Henry Cabot lodge


Why did president Woodrow Wilson decide against inviting Henry Cabot lodge to the peace conference at Versailles?

Wilson had strong personal feelins about lodge


What is Henry Cabot Lodge's birthday?

Henry Cabot Lodge was born on May 12, 1850.


When was Henry Cabot Lodge born?

Henry Cabot Lodge was born on May 12, 1850.


When was Henry Cabot Lodge House created?

Henry Cabot Lodge House was created in 1850.