Best Answer

Title I of the NRA was overturned by the U.S. Supreme Court on May 27, 1935 in a sweeping and unanimous ruling after hearing the A.L.A. Schechter Poultry Corp. v. United States case, in which the Schechter Corp. allegedly disobeyed the requirements of a "Code of Fair Competition for the Live Poultry Industry of the Metropolitan Area in and about the City of New York." In that Roosevelt-approved code, the company had failed to observe provisions fixing minimum wages and maximum hours for employees, permitted customers to select individual chickens, sold unfit chicken, were not in compliance with inspection regulations, had dealings with slaughterers and dealers not licensed under the code, and made false reports. The Supreme Court found that the provisions in the code were not a valid exercise of federal power. The court argued that Congress had given too much control to the presidency to issue whatever edicts it chose. The act also gave Congress excessive power to regulate interstate commerce and "invades the power reserved exclusively to the States." The court ruled that Congress did not have the right to dictate to the states wages and hours worked, because those factors affect costs and prices and therefore indirectly affect interstate commerce, "nor in the fact that failure of some States to regulate wages and hours diverts commerce from the States that do regulate them." The court also argued that there were no standards set for any trade, industry, or activity and therefore could not prescribe "rules of conduct" to be used when drafting these codes. By the time Title I was overturned, more than 700 industries had been codified, four million unemployed people had been absorbed into industrial jobs, and nearly 23 million workers were under codes. It was largely felt that by the time it was overturned, Title I had run its course and was no longer needed.

User Avatar

Wiki User

9y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Why did the supreme court strike down the natuonal industrial recovery?
Write your answer...
Still have questions?
magnify glass
Related questions

Did the supreme court strike down the AAA and NIRA as unconstitutional?

Yes, the Supreme Court struck down the AAA (Agricultural Adjustment Act) and the NIRA (National Industrial Recovery Act) as unconstitutional in separate cases. In 1936, the Court ruled that the AAA violated the Constitution by regulating agricultural production, and in 1935, it declared the NIRA unconstitutional for giving the executive branch excessive power.

Describe the 1894 Pullman strike as an example of industrial unrest?

An industrial unrest is a strike or boycott. So the Pullman Strike 0f 1894 is an example of a industrial unrest because it was also a strike that happened in the West side of Chicago.

What are the causes of industrial strike in nigeria?

examine the couses of industrial fairlure

What can a supreme court do if a law is unconstitutional?

Strike it down

What can the Supreme court do if a law is unconstitutional?

Strike it down

What motivated Franklin Delano Roosevelt to initiate the Second New Deal?

Criticism by liberal allies that the initial New Deal did not go far enough, and the Supreme Court's strike down of a key component of the legislation, the National Industrial Recovery Act, led to the Second New Deal. This included the Social Security Act, National Labor Relations Act, and the Works Progress Administration (WPA).

The great strike of 1877 took place in the?

Steel industrial

Why would the supreme court strike down a new land?

because it was......

What does the term judical review mean?

the ability of the Supreme Court to strike down acts of Congress.

How did population growth lead to industrial revolution?

Ff Strike

Did the industrial workers of the world never sufficiently organize to lead a successful strike?


What hareships did newsies face during the industrial revolution?

Not getting paid during their strike.