Representatives of the Third Estate were disappointed with the voting pattern in the Estates-General because each estate had only one vote, which meant that the privileged First and Second Estates could easily outvote the Third Estate, despite its larger population. This unfair system reinforced the existing social hierarchy and marginalized the interests of the common people. The Third Estate sought more equitable representation and voting procedures, which contributed to their eventual push for reform and the French Revolution.
The representatives of the Third Estate were disappointed with the pattern of voting in the Estates General because each estate was granted one vote, which meant that the combined votes of the privileged First and Second Estates (clergy and nobility) could easily outvote the Third Estate, despite it representing the vast majority of the population. This unequal voting structure reinforced their marginalization and lack of influence in decision-making processes. The Third Estate sought a more equitable system, such as voting by head, which would allow their larger numbers to hold more weight in legislative matters. This frustration ultimately contributed to their decision to break away and form the National Assembly.
Class antagonisms precluded unity of action in the Estates-General which convened at Versailles on May 5, 1789.
In preparation for the Estates General, Louis XVI had the three estates compile cahiers that stated their grievances against the government. There was also the formation of the National Assembly, which in turn started the Tennis Court Oaths.
the estate general and the English parliament are not the same.
Voting Procedure.
The trouble was the voting system. There were, of course, far more paople in the Third Estate, and it had far more delegates; but voting was not by head but by estates - so the other two could always outvote the Third.
Because he could. He was king and he could do whatever he wanted to.
The Estates General was deadlocked from the start primarily due to disagreements over voting procedures. The Third Estate, representing the common people, demanded that votes be counted by head rather than by estate, which would give them more influence. In contrast, the First and Second Estates (the clergy and nobility) preferred voting by estate, which would maintain their power. This fundamental disagreement over representation and voting rights led to a stalemate that contributed to the eventual outbreak of the French Revolution.
On May 5, 1789, in France, the Estates-General met for an elaborate voting of the government.
By voting together. Senior clergy (Bishops and Abbots) were appointed by the King, and mostly of the nobility. They naturally voted with the nobility, giving them a two-to-one majority over the Third Estate; voting was not by head (the Third Estate was far more numerous) but by Estate.
Estates General
King Phillip created the Estates General.
Estates General - France - was created in 1302.
Estates General - France - ended in 1789.
The Estates General was called at the discretion of the king. For 175 years, no monarch had chosen to call a meeting. Louis XVI was flummoxed over what to do about France's economic problems, as well as how voting should be done. The Third Estate was at a disadvantage when the vote went by estate, since the First and Second Estates tended to vote together.
What are the three key ideas in the meeting of the estates general?" what was the problem in the estates. what was the problem in the estates.