answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

The common criticism of the Constitution at the time it was ratified was that it was restricting people's freedom by pointing power in a centralized authority that was distant from the people, similar to the British government that had been overthrown only a few years earlier. It directly benefited the rich and powerful by providing order and authority to a system that benefited those at the economic and social top of the system.

That said the alternative was chaos. It probably would have led, at best, to a flat economy and divided people. At worst, it could have led to a bloodbath and Dictatorship similar to that following the French Revolution. Therefore, while the Constitution benefited the elites the most, it benefited just about everyone to some extent.

Before the Constitution was established, this idea was still apparent. Leading up to the drafting of the final Constitution, Shay's Rebellion arose in 1786. A revolt by the debtors and farmers to attempt to enforce their demands for lighter taxes and a suspension of property takeovers, this rebellion eventually influenced the passing of debtor-free laws. This event was one of the several causes to the drafting of the Constitution. Thomas Jefferson along with the elite feared that the country's initial fight for liberty was getting out of hand under republicanism, and were scared that they wouldn't get paid by their debtors and that they wouldn't have the political respect and power, as the poorer debtors were granted their wish. The idea for reconsidering the Articles of Confederation---the constitution under which Shay's Rebellion was led---arose out of this conservative want for a muscular central government. Many debtors feared that a powerful federal government such as the suggested one would force them to pay their creditors, and thus they protested the idea. But revisiting and, ultimately, redrafting the Articles of Confederation would benefit for the rich conservatives both economically and ideologically.

User Avatar

Aliza Upton

Lvl 13
2y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar
More answers
User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago

The common criticism of the Constitution at the time it was ratified was that it was restricting people's freedom by pointing power in a centralized authority that was distant from the people, similar to the British government that had been overthrown only a few years earlier. It directly benefited the rich and powerful by providing order and authority to a system that benefited those at the economic and social top of the system.

That said the alternative was chaos. It probably would have led, at best, to a flat economy and divided people. At worst, it could have led to a bloodbath and Dictatorship similar to that following the French Revolution. Therefore, while the Constitution benefited the elites the most, it benefited just about everyone to some extent.

Before the Constitution was established, this idea was still apparent. Leading up to the drafting of the final Constitution, Shay's Rebellion arose in 1786. A revolt by the debtors and farmers to attempt to enforce their demands for lighter taxes and a suspension of property takeovers, this rebellion eventually influenced the passing of debtor-free laws. This event was one of the several causes to the drafting of the Constitution. Thomas Jefferson along with the elite feared that the country's initial fight for liberty was getting out of hand under republicanism, and were scared that they wouldn't get paid by their debtors and that they wouldn't have the political respect and power, as the poorer debtors were granted their wish. The idea for reconsidering the Articles of Confederation---the constitution under which Shay's Rebellion was led---arose out of this conservative want for a muscular central government. Many debtors feared that a powerful federal government such as the suggested one would force them to pay their creditors, and thus they protested the idea. But revisiting and, ultimately, redrafting the Articles of Confederation would benefit for the rich conservatives both economically and ideologically.

This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: The US Constitution of 1787 represented an economic and ideological victory for the traditional American political elite. asses the validity of that statement for the period 1781-1789.?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Related questions

Americans that the declaration of independence and the constitution of 1787discuss the degree to which the constitution accomplishes the political and ideological goals that the declaration sets out?

The "question" needs to be re-stated; it's unintelligible in its current form....


What are the 5 basic motives for imperialism?

Economic Military Political Ideological Religous Exploritory


What are the minor political parties the parties apart from the Republicans and the Democrats?

Ideological parties Single-issue parties Economic protest parties Splinter parties *The biggest three are the Constitution, Green, and Libertarian.


What type of political system does Romania have?

According to the Constitution adopted in 1991, Romania is a parliamentary republic. Democratic rights and freedom are guaranteed by the Constitution. Romania is a multi-political party state - many parties are currently registered, but only important ones are represented in the Parliament.


How do you spell assanination?

The correct spelling is assassination (killing for a political or ideological reason).


How do you spell asasinate?

The correct spelling of the verb is "assassinate" (kill for political or ideological reasons).


What led to the renaissence?

Factors that led to the Renaissance such as ideological, cultural, economic, social and political.


What political parties supported Marxist thinking?

Communist, Socialist and Worker's parties.


What factors led to the Renaissance?

Factors that led to the Renaissance such as ideological, cultural, economic, social and political.


What political party is represented by an elephant?

The US Republican party is represented by an elephant.


How did the writings of enlightenment-era thinkers like john Locke and Montesquieu influence the American revolution?

These writings challenged traditional social, religious, and political values.


What is ideological discrimination?

Ideological discrimination is the discrimination that occurs due to having different ideas. For example, people may discriminate each other based on the political ideologies that they have, such as communism versus capitalism.